Do Twins Have A Secret Language?

Sorry it’s taken me so long to finish this three part series on language in twins. Snowed under while working from home and utterly exhausted before Christmas put a stop to my gallop! Back in action now and ready to go! We know that many things affect language development in twins: low birth weight, gender, genetic factors, the amount and quality of language input, less interaction with adults compared with children who are not twins, and intense interaction between the twins themselves. There’s a common belief that twins develop their own secret or private language called cryptophasia. Older research reports that twin language is unique for each set of twins and is not understood by others, including their parents. It has been reported to be used between twins in very specific situations such as playing together, in bed before going to sleep, and at meal time. And supposedly it tends to disappear by around age three. But what’s out there in the research about this? Once again, precious little it would seem…and a lot of it is quite dated. Let’s have a look at what I managed to dig up. I’ve kept the focus on the most recent research I could find with one exception.

First up is a 2013 study from Japan. The researchers looked at the relationship between twin language, twins’ close relationships (called close ties), and social competence. There were 261 twin pairs aged from 6-12 years included in the study. What did they find? I’m going to keep the focus here on twin language. They found that having an older sibling and attending preschool didn’t affect the close tie between twins, twin language, or social competence. One of their most important findings was that social competence was not directly affected by a close tie between twins. Social competence was affected when a twin language was found. Twins with a close tie were found to be more likely to have a twin language. The researchers claim that it’s possible that the twins’ close tie develops from birth to infancy, before the use of twin language. Their findings also suggest that twin language can influence social competence in school age children. Generally, it has been thought that intervention for twin language is unnecessary as most twin language tends to disappear spontaneously around age three. They found that twin language tended to emerge when one twin encouraged the other to use it and it had disappeared by age four. Twin language was used most frequently at age two. They also found that the twin language was made up of words and sentences from children’s TV programmes and adult conversations although the twins used them in their own, unique contexts.

Then I found a 2017 study from Lithuania which focused on one pair of twins: a boy and a girl. Their interaction was recorded two to four times a week in everyday situations for about one and half hours a month starting when they were two years and five months old. The summary of the study was in English and the whole paper was in Lithuanian which I can’t read! I’ve contacted the author for a summary in English and I’ll update the post once I have more details. The authors say that the results of their research “attest to manifestations of twin secret language, including the reaction of their parents”. That means they found evidence of twin language. They intend to carry out more detailed research in the future. Important to bear in mind here that the study only involves one set of twins.

Then I came across a 2017 book by Nancy Segal, Professor of Psychology at California State University, Fullerton and Director of the Twin Studies Centre. Here’s what she has to say: “Based on available studies, it is safe to say that about 40% of twin toddlers engage in some form of “twin-speak”. But that figure does not convey just how complex twins’ language development turns out to be.” When she delves more deeply into the issue of secret language, she says that it’s “differences in definitions, measurement methods, and the age at which twins are studied” that account for variations in the estimated frequency of twin language from “less than 2% to 47%”. She also points out that twins don’t produce a new language but that the private language is comprised of atypical forms of the language that they’re exposed to.

 

She goes into a lot of detail about distinctions between:

shared verbal understanding: speech used between twins also directed to other people even though it is unintelligible to these others and not ‘abnormal’ (her words!) in form.

private language : also unintelligible to others, and speech used exclusively within the twin pair. She reports that the “smaller number of twins (mostly male) at risk for language problems by the age of 6 are those who used private language at the age of 3 and did not develop normal language skills along with their private speech”

restricted language : ‘ordinary language dedicated to intimate communication between partners who share beliefs and expectations that come from a shared life history, and who use the same abbreviated expressions’. She gives an example from her own experience of talking about fried eggs that were not to her liking when she was a child. She would yell ‘gush gush’ and her mother would put them back in the frying pan. Her twin sister and herself still use the term today! This is just like the private jokes and made-up words shared in many families. So when thinking about twin language, it’s important to think about what we mean exactly.

Last up are two studies that looked in detail at the speech sound systems of multiple birth children (twins and triplets). The first one focused on English and the second one on Potunghua (an official language in China). They are quite dated in research terms (1994 and 2010) but I think they’re worth including here to give food for thought. Let’s start with the English one which involved 19 sets of two- to- four-year-old twins and triplets. They measured the children’s understanding of their twins’ or triplets’ context-free speech. They found that the children were prone to speech sound disorder. Siblings’ speech sound systems (the sounds they used when talking) were similar but not identical to each other. Multiple-birth children were better able to understand their siblings’ mispronunciations than other children of the same age. But that understanding did depend on how closely the mispronunciations were to the adult form. Multiple birth children may store two versions of how to say the same word: the adult form and their sibling’s form. That’s two sources of contradictory information that may give rise to unusual pronunciations. The researchers conclude that “while these three factors conspire to give the impression that ‘twin language’ is common, none of these findings provided support for the claim that multiple-birth children use an autonomous language”. Interesting…..

 

Several years later, one of the authors, Barbara Dodd and another colleague studied a set of identical twin boys who were six years and two months at the time of the study. The boys had no other siblings and were monolingual speakers of Putonghua. What did they find? The speech sound systems of the twins were not identical although they showed signs of impaired speech sound development and they shared some error patterns. They both understood their parents’ and their sibling’s pronunciations which again suggests a dual representation of some words in their mental dictionary. Same findings as for the English study six years previously. Important to remember though that there was only one set of twins involved in the Potunghua study

 

So that’s what some of the research says. There are lots of gaps there especially when it comes to recent research. What about your experience though?

.

 

What I read so you don’t have to

Balčiūnienė I. and Krivickaitė E. (2017) “Early language acquisition in twins: development and analysis of the Lithuanian Corpus”, Taikomoji kalbotyra, (9), pp. 31-45.

Dodd, B., & McEvoy, S. (1994) Twin language or phonological disorder? Journal of Child Language 21: 273-289.

Hayashi, C., Hiroshi, Mikami., Nishihara, R., Maeda, C., Hayakawa, K. (2013). The Relationship Between Twin Language, Twins’ Close Ties, and Social Competence. Twin Research & Human Genetics 17(1): 27-37.

Hua, Z. & Dodd, B. (2010) Phonological systems of a set of Potonghua speaking twins. International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders 35( 4): 487-506.

Segal, N. (2017). Twin mythconceptions: False beliefs, fables, and facts about twins. London: Elsevier.

163 Comments

  1. viagra canada online paypal online viagra viagra quiz [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra medicine prescription[/url] ’

  2. inexpensive real cialis what color is cialis pill cheap cialis pills uk [url=http://cialijomen.com/]cialis sale[/url] ’

  3. where can i buy cialis online in canada taking cialis and viagra together cialis without prescription [url=http://21cialismen.com/]buy voucher for cialis daily online[/url] ’

  4. indian cialis generic cheap cialis uk buy cialis cheapest [url=http://mycialedst.com/]dapoxetine/cialis[/url] ’

  5. generic viagra online us buy female viagra australia viagra in sacramento [url=http://genericrxxx.com/]viagra dapoxetine[/url] ’

  6. cialis and viagra taken together cialis pills online generic cialis and overnight [url=http://21cialismen.com/]cialis on line paypal payment[/url] ’

  7. generic cialis australia cialis ebay viagra • cialis • [url=http://cialijomen.com/]how much is a cialis prescription with no insurance[/url] ’

  8. answers to get viagra viagra and celexa viagra online [url=http://acialaarx.com/]buying viagra from canada[/url] ’

  9. canadien pharmacy no prescription cialis viagra sampleviagra cialis cialis with dapoxetine [url=http://loncialis.com/]generic cialis[/url] ’

  10. viagra for sale in usa paypal drug store viagra pfizer viagra patent [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra online ireland[/url] ’

  11. viagra worldwide can i pay for viagra from paypal account? viagra australia [url=http://genqpviag.com/]trial pack cialis viagra levitro[/url] ’

  12. achat viagra canada low price generic viagra viagra online [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra preГ§o[/url] ’

  13. viagra store in bangladesh viagra vs cialis/strong> natural viagra over the counter [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra cialis comparison[/url] ’

  14. viagra in india drug categories viagra cialis discount viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]mexican viagra fast delivery[/url] ’

  15. why buy cialis. com cialis without a prescription cialis on sale [url=http://cialmenshoprx.com/]cocaine cialis[/url] ’

  16. online super viagra australia buy viagra online best viagra alternatives [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra erectile dysfunction pills[/url] ’

  17. viagra. buy brand viagra online best place to buy viagra paypal [url=http://genqpviag.com/]buy viagra on gold coast[/url] ’

  18. buy viagra brisbane purchase viagra online no prescription needed indianapolis viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]malaysia online viagra buying[/url] ’

  19. best viagra alternatives buy viagra craigslist toronto viagra prescrition for walgreens [url=http://llviabest.com/]ingredient in viagra[/url] ’

  20. female viagra wikipedia no prescription viagra vipp quick delivery on viagra [url=http://genqpviag.com/]canadian pharmacy generic viagra[/url] ’

  21. viagra ireland online generic viagra for sale viagra 100 mg best price [url=http://genqpviag.com/]brand viagra online[/url] ’

  22. viagra web sites grapefruit and viagra cheap viagra on line [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra generic[/url] ’

  23. viagra 100 mg price discount viagra india viagras 100mg [url=http://llviabest.com/]cvs viagra[/url] ’

  24. how much costs viagra in india youtube viagra prices viagra professional buy online [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra online rx pharmacy[/url] ’

  25. buy pfizer viagra viagra overnight in uk average age for viagra [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra online usa[/url] ’

  26. buying viagra montreal kaboom viagra viagra payment paypal [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra in hong kong[/url] ’

  27. womens viagra what are the different types of viagra levitra vs viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]alternative ti viagra[/url] ’

  28. insurance that covers cialis cialis В® for daily use best price for cialis 20mg [url=http://loncialis.com/]cialis prescription online[/url] ’

  29. viagra vs cialis reviews chip viagra toronto viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]buy viagra in canada[/url] ’

  30. cheap generic viagra online australia viagra sub illegal viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]buy viagra online overnight delivery[/url] ’

  31. viagra canada health care products,viagra toronto viagra refractory period [url=http://genqpviag.com/]overnight me viagra[/url] ’

  32. where to buy viagra in edmonton free viagra samples australia viagra rapid tabs [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra nz[/url] ’

  33. viagra without prescription\’ what does viagra cost in uk viagra 500mg [url=http://genqpviag.com/]cheap viagra generic 100mg[/url] ’

  34. soft gel cialis discount cialis cialis as generic [url=http://sjcialis.com/]cialis for daily use side effects[/url] ’

  35. viagra brand viking pfizer viagra online viagra super force 100mg 60mg pills [url=http://genqpviag.com/]generic viagra[/url] ’

  36. buy viagra without presciption i want to order some viagra viagra paypal [url=http://xz-pharmacyonline.com/en/career-opportunities.html]pfizer viagra 100mg online[/url] ’

  37. buy generic viagra reviews buy viagra 100 mg australianviagraonline [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra super force[/url] ’

  38. viagra 100mg cost viagra u viagra canada overnight [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra windsor canada[/url] ’

  39. purchase viagra buy generic viagra online delivery fast viagra for women australia [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra headquarters[/url] ’

  40. viagra no prescription viagra online stores buy viagra with paypal [url=https://canadianpharmacy-usx.com/organic.htm]buy viagra onlinne[/url] ’

  41. cialis samples online buy online prescription drugs cialis capsules canada [url=https://xz-pharmacyonline.com]trusted overseas pharmacies[/url] ’

  42. viagra in ukВ  is posssible buy viagra no prescription at walgrees? buying viagra in australia [url=http://genqpviag.com/]online viagra in australia[/url] ’

  43. cheep viagra pfizer viagra 100mg price viagra australia buy [url=http://genqpviag.com/]generic viagra scam[/url] ’

  44. how to use tinder , how to use tinder
    [url=”http://tinderdatingsiteus.com/?”]what is tinder [/url]

  45. cheep viagra viagra 160 mg viagra american express [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra side effects blood pressure[/url] ’

  46. discount viagra viagra online order viagra without prescriptions [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra walmart[/url] ’

  47. viagra 4 sale before and after viagra pics genelic viagra [url=http://genqpviag.com/]pfizer viagra[/url] ’

  48. best place to buy viagra paypal sale viagra for men over the counter viagra walgreens [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra brand 100mg[/url] ’

  49. viagra soft tabs buyviagra buy wholesale viagra [url=http://genqpviag.com/]cheap canada viagra[/url] ’

  50. viagra paypal overnight cheap viagra how to take viagra [url=http://genqpviag.com/]generic viagra sale[/url] ’

  51. Great items from you, man. I’ve take note your stuff prior to and you are simply extremely great.

    I really like what you’ve acquired right here, certainly like what you are saying and the
    way in which wherein you say it. You make it enjoyable and
    you still care for to stay it smart. I cant
    wait to read much more from you. This is actually
    a wonderful website.

  52. viagra usa online generic viagra with mastercard viagra for sale uk [url=http://genqpviag.com/]photos of real viagra[/url] ’

  53. buy viagra on line in brisbane best prices for viagra viagra from china [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra dosage instructions[/url] ’

  54. cheapviagra order viagra online in australia buying real viagra online [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra herbs[/url] ’

  55. which pharmacy can i buy viagra in london viagra no prescription fast shipping viagra 100mg cost [url=http://llviabest.com/]buy viagra australia online no prescription[/url] ’

  56. viagra for sale viagra in uae viagra price [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra sales astralia[/url] ’

  57. Nice blog here! Also your site loads up fast! What web host are you using?

    Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  58. cialis tadalafil paypal cialis daily use cialis price [url=http://sjcialis.com/]do i need prescription for cialis in usa[/url] ’

  59. viagra cialis levitra online mexico pharmacy, viagra windsor canada viagra [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra worldwide[/url] ’

  60. over 40 and viagra cheap generic viagra dizzy right after viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra paypal in australia[/url] ’

  61. cialis purchase best online international pharmacies cialis 20mg 30 [url=https://xz-pharmacyonline.com]Top Avana[/url] ’

  62. Hi to all, since I am genuinely eager of reading this website’s
    post to be updated regularly. It includes good material.

  63. cialis, levetra, viagra for less brand viagra with dapoxetine viagra 100 [url=http://llviabest.com/]brand viagra australia[/url] ’

  64. viagra 25mg vs 50mg drugstore 1st viagra buy viagra no prescription, paypal [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra for sale uk[/url] ’

  65. viagra uk online cheap generic viagra viagra shoppers drug mart [url=https://canadianpharmacy-usx.com/organic.htm]original viagra[/url] ’

  66. ebay cialis cialis viagra sales cialis sales canadian [url=http://cialmenshoprx.com/]cialis free offer[/url] ’

  67. viagra online sales buy viagra without prisciption cheap viagra south africa [url=http://xz-pharmacyonline.com/en/career-opportunities.html]ireland manufacturer viagra[/url] ’

  68. how to buy viagra in shanghai viagra online aus chinese viagra pills [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra professional super[/url] ’

  69. viagra sales aurtarlia buy viagra without perscription vegas viagra local [url=http://genqpviag.com/]buying viagra italy[/url] ’

  70. can i buy viagra online without percription viagra 100mg canada female viagra pills australia [url=http://genqpviag.com/]walgreen viagra cost per pill[/url] ’

  71. viagra and dapoxine viagra prices at walmart 150 mg viagra [url=http://genqpviag.com/]phone number for cheap viagras in fl[/url] ’

  72. viagra gum viagra without a prescription viagra sof tabs overnight delivery [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra on line[/url] ’

  73. viagra and dapoxetine viagra 36 canada viagra 20mg shopping [url=http://erectilejyzd.com/index.php?called=terms]viagra without persciction[/url] ’

  74. chinese viagra pills viagra online sweden buy generic viagra canada [url=http://llviabest.com/]where can i get viagra across the counter in the uk[/url] ’

  75. viagra in hamburg best alternative to viagra quik ship viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]purchase viagra with paypal[/url] ’

  76. super viagra uk viagra generic 100mg 365 pills viagra with dapoxetine [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra[/url] ’

  77. viagra generic india mastercard viagra for sale perth buy brand name viagra online [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra for sale[/url] ’

  78. paypal viagra viagra 100mm viagra on line [url=http://genqpviag.com/]best place to buy viagra in sydney[/url] ’

  79. cialis canadian prescription drugstore cialis buy [url=https://impotencecdny.com/]anti viral[/url] ’

  80. generic viagra overnight viagra 50mg buy viagra in sydney australia [url=http://genqpviag.com/]buy viagra super force[/url] ’

  81. viagra price in india viagra pill viagra in india [url=http://llviabest.com/]usa viagra overnight[/url] ’

  82. levitra vs cialis vs viagra which one is better viagra cialis or laverta how much does a prescription of viagra cost [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra and headaches[/url] ’

  83. viagra paypal viagra tijuana get viagra overnight [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra prices[/url] ’

  84. how to get viagra generic viagra with daposetine viagra price in india [url=http://llviabest.com/]brand viagra[/url] ’

  85. browse tinder for free , tinder sign up
    tinder app

  86. viagra where to buy in malaysia generic viagra purchase with mastercard what is better viagra or cialis or levitra?? [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra for sale us[/url] ’

  87. buy real viagra generic viagra mastercard viagra en sydney [url=http://genqpviag.com/]buy viagra paypal[/url] ’

  88. overnight pharmacy viagra generic vs brand name viagra viagra [url=http://erectilejyzd.com/index.php?called=terms]viagra paypal[/url] ’

  89. viagra uk ebay viagra pills viagra mexico walmart [url=http://llviabest.com/]where to buy viagra chemist austrlia[/url] ’

  90. cheap viagra reviews walmart viagra cost viagra sources [url=http://llviabest.com/]buy viagra and prescription drugs[/url] ’

  91. cialis 20 mg best price for cialis 20mg cialis omline [url=https://impotencecdny.com/info/history.php]what is brand cialis[/url] ’

  92. viagra no precription travel taipei viagra online order mastercard accepted wholesale viagra 100mg [url=http://llviabest.com/]kamagra vs viagra[/url] ’

  93. sildenafil 50 mg buy online price cheapest generic viagra prices sildenafil pills [url=http://canadianpharmacy-yy.com/Fitness/how-to-get-a-six-pack.html]generic women viagra[/url] ’

  94. indian pharmacy Suhagra web medical information [url=https://canadianpharmacy-yy.com/]Doxazosin[/url] ’

  95. viagra tablets for sell Imuran brand viagra trial pack [url=http://erectilejyzd.com/]erection pills[/url] ’

  96. 365 pills viagra cialis professional viagra cheap au viagra sources [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra pay by paypal[/url] ’

  97. viagra n line buy viagra soft no prescription viagra cheap generic cialis [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra mexico walmart[/url] ’

  98. viagra premature ejaculation treatment buy female viagra in australia viagra online [url=http://llviabest.com/]united states viagra online[/url] ’

  99. viagrasites best cheap website for viagra viagra with out prescription [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra expiration[/url] ’

  100. nz viagra cheap viagra no prescription lowest price viagra no prescription [url=http://genqpviag.com/]i want to try viagra[/url] ’

  101. cost of viagra at walmart viagra onlnine viagra for sale sa [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra online no prescription[/url] ’

  102. best online viagra source generic viagra india online buy viagra online in japan [url=http://llviabest.com/]how can i get free viagra[/url] ’

  103. Heya i am for the first time here. I found this board and I find
    It truly useful & it helped me out much. I hope to give something
    back and aid others like you aided me.

  104. craigslist and viagra pfizer viagra without presciption sildenafil citrate (generic viagra) [url=http://genqpviag.com/]buy viagra online paypal[/url] ’

  105. cialis 20 mg tablets generic cialis in usa buy brand cialis [url=https://impotencecdny.com/info/history.php]back pain from cialis[/url] ’

  106. viagra paypal viagra buy through paypal generic viagra canada customs [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra in south africa[/url] ’

  107. buy viagra craigslist toronto viagra gold 365 pills viagra cialis professional [url=http://genqpviag.com/]where to buy viagra without prescription?[/url] ’

  108. viagra coupons prescription drugs online without order viagra online nb canada [url=http://erectilejyzd.com/]rx pharmacy[/url] ’

  109. quick ship viagra viagra online legality viagra in dublin [url=http://genqpviag.com/]cheap viagra pills online[/url] ’

  110. gneeric viagra online viagra au how much for viagra without insurance [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra[/url] ’

  111. viagra from canada paypal viagra 100mg price female pink viagra online [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagrasales[/url] ’

  112. tinder website , browse tinder for free
    [url=”http://tinderdatingsiteus.com/?”]tinder login[/url]

  113. usa viagra viagra super active free shipping viagra 50 mg generic buy [url=http://genqpviag.com/]buy viagra online overnight delivery[/url] ’

  114. viagra effects on men viagra para hombres viagra/cialis packs [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra without prescription[/url] ’

  115. buy viagra online generic actually pay with paypal viagra to buy viagra super force in london [url=http://genqpviag.com/]where can i buy viagra in exeter[/url] ’

  116. discount pharmaceuticals canada drugs online pharmacy Avana [url=https://canadianpharmacy-yy.com/]Feldene[/url] ’

  117. viagra gold overnight where i can purchase viagra priligy viagra australia [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra george south africa[/url] ’

  118. viagra professional viagra online nz authentic viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]actual prescription cost of viagra[/url] ’

  119. cialis cost nz compare prescription prices cipla cialis [url=https://impotencecdny.com/]canadia online pharmacy[/url] ’

  120. viagra soft generic generic viagra lowest prices sildenafil citrate 100 [url=http://canadianpharmacy-yy.com/Fitness/how-to-get-a-six-pack.html]cheap viagra 100mg uk[/url] ’

  121. [url=http://luckypharmusa.online/]canadian pharmacy viagra 100mg[/url] [url=http://cialispil.com/]online cialis canada[/url] [url=http://unicialis.com/]cialis uk pharmacy[/url] [url=http://orderzovirax.online/]zovirax 400 price[/url] [url=http://tadalafilpak.com/]cialis 5 mg tablet price[/url]

  122. ordering viagra through paypal viagra paypal canada payment how to get viagra in dubai [url=http://llviabest.com/]acheter viagra[/url] ’

  123. viagra canada generic viagra where to buy viagra for sale in the uk [url=http://genqpviag.com/]viagra cheap[/url] ’

  124. viagra premature ejaculation buy viagra and prescription drugs viagra substitute online [url=http://llviabest.com/]cialis vs viagra reviews[/url] ’

  125. cheap viagra mastercard retail sale of viagra in toronto allergy of viagra [url=http://llviabest.com/]viagra online ireland[/url] ’

  126. where to buy viagra in melbourne viagra blue vision buy viagra online [url=http://llviabest.com/]top online generic viagra[/url] ’

  127. overnight shipping on viagra cheap canada viagra best place to buy viagra paypal [url=http://llviabest.com/]top sale viagracialis[/url] ’

  128. no prescription viagra vipp viagra and headaches viagra inline [url=http://llviabest.com/]buy viagra in canada[/url] ’